12^th REGIONAL MOOT COURT COMPETITION IN HUMAN RIGHTS

Skopje, 19-20^th May 2018

OFFICIAL RECORDS

PART I
Grades for the written briefs

Club	City	Applicant	Response	Total	Place
Discretio	Mostar	29.5	31	60.5	5
Gavro Vukovic	Podgorica	27.5	27.5	55	10
Gorgija	Zenica	31.5	33	64.5	4
Henrik Steska	Ljubljana	37	37	74	1
Iustitia	Nis	33	32	65	3
Iudex	Sarajevo	30	30	60	6
Iustiniana Prima	Skopje	31	29	60	6
Nasciturus	Split	28	27	55	10
Dr Radomir Lukic	Novi Sad	29	28	57	8
Virtus, Scentia,Veritas	Vlora	29.5	27	56.5	9
Vladimir Bayer	Zagreb	36	35.5	71.5	2
Zoran Kompanjet	Rijeka	30	29.5	59.5	7

Written briefs ranking by city

1. Ljubljana (Henrik Steska)

2. Zagreb (Vladimir Bayer)

3. Nis (Iustitia)

4. Zenica (Gorgija)

5. Mostar (Discretio)

6. Sarajevo (Iudex

6. Skopje (Iustiniana Prima)

7. Rijeka (Zoran Kompanjet)

8. Novi Sad (Dr Radomir Lukic)

9. Vlora (Virtus, Scientia, Veritas)

10. Podgorica (Gavro Vukovic)

10. Split (Nasciturus)

PART II
Draw

According to written briefs grades, Club “Henrik Steska”, Ljubljana (74), Club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb (71.5), Club “Iustitia”, Nis (65) and Club “Gorgija”, Zenica (64.5) were placed in the first box. After the first draw, Club “Gorgija”, Zenica was selected for the leader of group A, Club “Iustitia”, Nis was selected for the leader of group B, Club “Henrik Steska”, Ljubljana was selected for the leader of group C and Club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb was selected for the group D.

According to the written briefs grades, Club “Discretio”, Mostar (60.5), Club “Iudex”, Sarajevo (60), Club “Iustiniana Prima”, Skopje (60) and Club “Zoran Kompanjet”, Rijeka (59.5) were placed in the second box. After the second draw Club “Iustiniana Prima”, Skopje was selected for the group A, Club “Iudex”, Sarajevo was selected for the group B, Club “Zoran Kompanjet”, Rijeka was selected for the group C and Club “Discretio”, Mostar was selected for the group D.

According to the written briefs grades, Club “Dr Radomir Lukic”, Novi Sad (57), Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas”, Vlora (56.5), Club “Gavro Vukovic”, Podgorica (55) and Club “Nasciturus”, Split (55) were placed in the third box. After the third draw Club “Dr Radomir Lukic”, Novi Sad was selected for the group A, Club “Nasciturus”, Split was selected for the group B, Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas”, Vlora was selected for the group C and Club “Gavro Vukovic”, Podgorica was selected for the group D.

Groups/Divisions

A

Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Club “Dr Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

B

Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Club “Nasciturus” (Split)

C

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas” (Vlora)

D

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

PART III

Matches in groups/divisions (May 19)

Match I

Applicant: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Respondent: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Judges: Vujić, Damjanovska, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Vujić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Damjanovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 23

Respondent: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 22

Match II

Applicant: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Respondent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Judges: Zupančič, Juras, Vuković

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupančič	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Juras	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Vuković	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 33

Respondent: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 12

Match III

Applicant: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Respondent: Club “Dr Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

Judges: Damjanovska, Nenadić, Vuković

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Damjanovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Vuković	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 24

Respondent: Club “Dr Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad) 21

Match IV

Applicant: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Respondent: Club “Nasciturus” (Split)

Judges: Nikolovska, Martinović, Juras

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolovska	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Martinović	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 3	R 0
Juras	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 30

Respondent: Club “Nasciturus” (Split) 15

Match V

Applicant: Club “Dr Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Respondent: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Judges: Vuković, Martinović, Nikolić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Vuković	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Martinović	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nikolić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Dr Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 19

Respondent: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 26

Match VI

Applicant: Club “Nasciturus” (Split)

Respondent: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judges: Damjanovska, Nikolovska, Djonova

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Damjanovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Djonova	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Nasciturus” (Split) 21

Respondent: Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 24

Match VII

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respondent: Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Judges: Nikolić, Djonova, Saiti

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Djonova	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Saiti	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 26

Respondent: Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 19

Match VIII

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respondent: Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

Judges: Martinović, Vujić, Marijan

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Vujić	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Marijan	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Respondent: Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 22

Match IX

Applicant: Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Respondent: Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas” (Vlora)

Judges: Devaja, Marijan, Zupančič

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Devaja	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Marijan	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Zupančič	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 24

Respondent: Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas” (Vlora) 21

Match X

Applicant: Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

Respondent: Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

Judges: Nikolovska, Nikolić, Vujić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nikolić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vujić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 22

Respondent: Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica) 23

Match XI

Applicant: Club “Virtus, Scientias, Veritas” (Vlora)

Respondent: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Zupančič, Marijan, Devaja

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupančič	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Marijan	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Devaja	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Virtus, Scientias, Veritas” (Vlora) 16

Respondent: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 29

Match XII

Applicant: Club “Gavro Vukovic (Podgorica)

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Vujić, Juras, Vuković

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Vujić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Juras	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Vuković	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Gavro Vukovic (Podgorica) 22

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Final results in all groups/divisions

A

Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 49

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 46

Club “Dr Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad) 40

B

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 50

Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 49

Club “Nasciturus” (Split) 36

C

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 55

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 43

Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas” (Vlora) 37

D

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 46

Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica) 45

Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 44

PART IV
Semi-finals (May 20)

Draw

Four best clubs from each group/division and two second-best clubs participated in the semi-finals. According to the draw results, groups E and F were formed:

E

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

F

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Matches in semi-final groups (May 20)

Match XIII

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respondent: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Judges: Juras, Martinović, Vuković

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Juras	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vuković	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Respondent: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 22

Match XIV

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respondent: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Judges: Nikolić, Nikolovska, Vujić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vujić	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 23

Respondent: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 22

Match XV

Applicant: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

Respondent: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judges: Zupančič, Vuković, Djonova

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupančič	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vuković	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Djonova	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 22

Respondent: Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 23

Match XVI

Applicant: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Respondent: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Judges: Nikolić, Vujić, Juras

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vujić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Juras	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 23

Respondent: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 22

Match XVII

Applicant: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Marijan, Djonova, Nikolić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Marijan	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Djonova	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Nikolić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 22

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Match XVIII

Applicant: Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Respondent: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Juras, Nenadić, Vujić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Juras	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Vujić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 23

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 22

Final results in the semi-finals

E

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 46

Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 45

Club “Gorgija” (Zenica) 44

F

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 45

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 45

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 45

PART V

Finals (May 20)

Match XIX

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respondent: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Zupančič, Martinović, Marijan, Nikolovska, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupančič	A 4	R 3	A 1	R 4	A 1	R 2
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Marijan	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Nenadić	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 35

Respondent: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 40

Match XX

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Zupančič, Martinović, Marijan, Nikolovska, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupančič	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Marijan	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 33

Respondent: Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 42

PART VI

The winner

The Club “Vladimir Bayer” from Zagreb is the winner of the 12^th Regional Moot Court Competition with 77 points, while Club “Henrik Steska” from Ljubljana won the second place with 73 points.

PART VII

The final results of the second part of the competition

1. Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

2. Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

3. Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

4. Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

4. Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

6. Club “Gorgija” (Zenica)

7. Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

8. Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

9. Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

10. Club “Dr Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

11. Club “Virtus, Scientia, Veritas” (Vlora)

12. Club “Nasciturus” (Split)

Belgrade Secretary of the Administrative Board

22 May, 2018 Goran Miletic