The Fifth Regional Moot Court Competition

Ohrid, 15-17 April 2011

Official records

PART I

Grades for the written briefs

Club “Iustiniana Prima”, Skopje (Macedonia)

Application: 35 State response: 36 Total: 71

Club “Iustitia”, Nis (Serbia)

Application: 34 State response: 33 Total: 67

Club “Slobodan Jovanovic”, Belgrade (Serbia)

Application: 32 State response: 31 Total: 63

Club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb (Croatia)

Application: 39 State response: 39 Total: 78

Club “Gavro Vukovic”, Podgorica (Montenegro)

Application: 28 State response: 28 Total: 56

Club “Radomir Lukic”, Novi Sad (Serbia)

Application: 37 State response: 38 Total: 75

Club “Iudex”, Sarajevo (Bosnia and Herzegovina)

Application: 37 State response: 38 Total: 75

Club “Zoran Komapnjet”, Rijeka (Croatia)

Application: 39 State response: 39 Total: 78

Club “Henrik Steske”, Ljubljana (Slovenia)

Application: 39 State response: 36 Total: 75

Club “Discretio”, Mostar (Bosnia and Herzegovina)

Application: 38 State response: 37 Total: 75

PART II

Draw

According to written briefs grades, Club “Zoran Kompanjet”, Rijeka (78) and Club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb (78) were placed in the first box together with two out of four that got 75 points for written briefs. After the first draw Club “Vladimir Bayer” was selected for the leader of group A, Club “Iudex”, Sarajevo for the leader of group B, club “Discretio”, Mostar for the leader of group C and club “Zoran Kompanjet” Rijeka for the leader of group D.

According to draw and grades for written briefs, club “Slobodan Jovanovic”, Belgrade and club “Henrik Steske”, Ljubljana were selected for the group A, while clubs “Iustitia” Nis and “Radomir Lukic” Novi Sad were selected for group B. Club “Gavro Vukovic” Podgorica was selected for group C and club “Iustiniana Prima” Skopje for club D.

Groups/divisions

A

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Slobodan Jovanovic” (Belgrade)

Club “Henrik Steske” (Ljubljana)

B

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

C

Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

D

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Note: Club “Slobodan Jovanovic” Belgrade, decided to withdraw from the Competition and group A was consisted of two clubs.

PART III

Matches in groups/divisions

(April 16)

Group A:

Applicant:“Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Nikolovska, Trajkovska, Pažin

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Trajkovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Pažin	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 7

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 11+2 bonus points =13

Group A:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Zupancic, Popovic, Mostovac

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 1	R 2	A 0	R 2	A 1	R 0
Popovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Mostovac	A 2	R 1	A 0	R 2	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 7

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 11 (+2 bonus points) = 13

Group B:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judges: Đuranovic, Caric, Martinovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Đuranovic	A 2	R 1	A 0	R 2	A 1	R 0
Caric	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Martinovic	A 3	R 0	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo) 11 (+2 bonus points) = 13

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis) 7

Group B:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Niš)

Respodent: “Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

Judges: Đuranovic, Caric, Martinovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Đuranovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Caric	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Martinovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Niš) 10+2 bonus points = 12

Respodent: “Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad) 8

Group B:

Applicant:“Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Judges: Đuranovic, Caric, Martinovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Đuranovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Caric	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Martinovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 8

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 10 + 2 bonus points = 12

Group C:

Applicant:“Discretio” (Mostar)

Respodent: “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

Judges: Zupancic, Trajkovska, Popovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Trajkovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Popovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant: “Discretio” (Mostar) 10+2 bonus points = 12

Respodent: “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica) 8

Group C:

Applicant:“Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar)

Judges: Zupancic, Trajkovska, Popovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Trajkovska	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Popovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica) 8

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar) 10+2 bonus points = 12

Group D:

Applicant:“Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Judges: Pazin, Mostovac, Nikolovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Pazin	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Mostovac	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Nikolovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 6

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 12 (+2 bonus points) = 14

Group D:

Applicant: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Judges: Pazin, Mostovac, Nikolovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Pazin	A 0	R 3	A 0	R 2	A 0	R 1
Mostovac	A 2	R 1	A 2	R 0	A 1	R 0
Nikolovska	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 9

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 9

Final results in all groups/divisions

A

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 20

Club “Henrik Steske” (Ljubljana) 20

B

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 25

Club “Iustitia” (Niš) 19

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 16

C

Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 24

Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica) 16

D

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 23

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 15

PART IV

Semi-final

(April 17)

Draw

Four best clubs from each group/divisions and two second-best clubs were participated in the semi-final. According to draw results, groups E and F were formed:

E

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

F

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

Club “Henrik Steske” (Ljubljana)

Matches in semi-final groups

(April 17)

Group E:

Applicant:“Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Popovic, Pazin, Đuranovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Popovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Pazin	A 1	R 2	A 0	R 2	A 0	R 1
Đuranovic	A 1	R 2	A 0	R 2	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 6

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 12+2 bonus points = 14

Group E:

Applicant: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judges: Nikolovska, Zupancic, Đuranovic

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Zupancic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Đuranovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 8

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis) 10 (+2 bonus points) = 12

Group E:

Applicant: “Iustitia” (Nis)

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Judges: Zupancic, Mostovac, Pazin

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Mostovac	A 2	R 1	A 2	R 0	A 0	R 1
Pazin	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Iustitia” (Nis) 10+ 2 bonus points = 12

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 8

Group F:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar)

Judges: Nikolovska, Martinović, Mostovac

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nikolovska	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Martinovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Mostovac	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo) 9

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar) 9

Group F:

Applicant:“Discretio” (Mostar)

Respodent: “Henrik Steske” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Trajkovska, Pazin, Mostovac

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Trajkovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Pazin	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Mostovac	A 1	R 2	A 0	R 2	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant: “Discretio” (Mostar) 7

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 11+2 bonus points = 13

Group F:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Judges: Đuranovic, Popovic, Trajkovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Đuranovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Popovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Trajkovska	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 10 (+2 bonus points) = 12

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 8

Final results in semi-final

E

Club “Iustitia” (Nis) 24

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 22

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 14

F

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 25

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 17

Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 16

PART V

Final

(April 17)

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Nis)

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Zupancic, Popovic, Martinovic, Nikolovska, Trajkovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Popovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Martinovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Nikolovska	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Trajkovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0

Total:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Nis) 17

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 13

Applicant: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judges: Zupancic, Popovic, Martinovic, Nikolovska, Trajkovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Zupancic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Popovic	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Martinovic	A 2	R 1	A 1	R 1	A 0	R 1
Nikolovska	A 1	R 2	A 1	R 1	A 1	R 0
Trajkovska	A 2	R 1	A 2	R 0	A 0	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 17

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Nis) 13

PART VI

The winner

Having in mind that both clubs in the final (club “Henrik Steska” from Ljubljana and “Iustitia” from Nis) have the same number of points, judges has voted for the winner:

Judge Zupancic: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judge Popović: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judge Martinovic: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judge Nikolovska: Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

Judge Trajkovska: Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Consequently, the Club “Iustitia” from Nis is the winner of the fifth Regional Moot Court Competition.

PART VII

The final results of the second part of the competition

1. Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

2. Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

3. Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

4. Club “Iudex”(Sarajevo)

5. Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

6. Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

7. Club “Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

8. Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

9. Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Belgrade, Secretary of the

Administrative Board

19 April 2011 Goran Miletić