The Seventh Regional Moot Court Competition

Ljubljana, 19-21 April 2013

Official records

PART I

Grades for the written briefs

Club	City	Application	Response	Total	Place
Vladimir Bayer	Zagreb	36	38	74	4
Zoran Kompanjet	Rijeka	35	37	72	5
Radomir Lukic	Novi Sad	37	38	75	3
Iudex	Sarajevo	32	34	66	7
Iustiniana Prima	Skopje	26	27	53	11
Discretio	Mostar	30	27	57	9
American College University	Skopje	29	27	56	10
Gavro Vukovic	Podgorica	27	25	52	12
Henrik Steska	Ljubljana	39	38	77	2
Iustitia	Nis	39	39	78	1
Nasciturus	Split	31	33	64	8
Dzemal Bijedic	Mostar	35	35	70	6

PART II

Draw

According to written briefs grades, Clubs “Iustitia”, Nis (78) “Henrik Steska”, Ljubljana (77), “Radomir Lukić”, Novi Sad (75) and Club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb (74) were placed in the first box. After the first draw Club “Henrik Steska” Ljubljana was selected for the leader of group A, Club “Iustitia”, Nis for the leader of group B, club “Vladimir Bayer”, Zagreb for the leader of group C and club “Radomir Lukić” Novi Sad for the leader of group D.

According to written briefs grades, Clubs “Zoran Kompanjet” Rijeka (72), Dzemal Bijedic (70), “Iudex”, Sarajevo (66), and “Nasciturus”, Split (64) were placed in the second box. After the second draw Club “Nasciturus” Split was selected for the group A, Club “Iudex”, Sarajevo for the group B, club “Dzemal Bijedic”, Mostar for the group C and club “Zoran Kompanjet” Rijeka for the group D.

According to written briefs grades, Clubs “Discretio”, Mostar (57), “American College University”, Skopje (56), “Iustiniama Prima”, Skopje (53) and “Gavro Vukovic”, Podgorica (52) were placed in the third box. After the third draw Club “Iustiniana Prima” Skopje was selected for the group A, Club “Discretio”, Mostar for the group B, club “American College University”, Skopje for the group C and club “Gavro Vukovic” Podgorica for the group D.

Groups/divisions

A

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Club “Nasciturus” (Split)

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

B

Club”Iustitia” (Nis)

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

C

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

Club “American College University” (Skopje)

D

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Club “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica)

PART III

Matches in groups/divisions

(April 20)

Group A:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Nasciturus” (Split)

Judges: Pažin, Nikolovska, Popović

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Pažin	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Nikolovska	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Popović	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 30

Respodent: “Nasciturus” (Split) 15

Group A:

Applicant: “Nasciturus” (Split)

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Judges: Katić, Popović, Trajkovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Katić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Popović	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Trajkovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Nasciturus” (Split) 24

Respodent: “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 21

Group A:

Applicant:“Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Popović,Trajkovska, Rovšek

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Popović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Trajkovska	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Rovšek	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant:“Iustiniama Prima” (Skopje) 21

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 24

Group B:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Niš)

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Judges: Ribičič, Nenadić, Martinović

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Ribičič	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Martinovic	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Niš) 26

Respodent: “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 19

Group B:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo)

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar)

Judges: Martinović, Pažin, Nikolovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Martinović	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Pažin	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Iudex” (Sarajevo) 24

Respodent: “Discretio” (Mostar) 21

Group B:

Applicant:“Discretio” (Mostar)

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Niš)

Judges: Martinović, Carić, Katić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Carić	A 2	R 5	A 1	R 4	A 1	R 2
Katić	A 2	R 5	A 1	R 4	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Discretio” (Mostar) 16

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Niš) 29

Group C:

Applicant:“Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respodent: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

Judges: Carić, Pažin,Zupančić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Carić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Pažin	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Zupančić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 26

Respodent: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 19

Group C:

Applicant:“Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

Respodent: “American College University” (Skopje)

Judges: Pažin, Vučinić, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Pažin	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vučinić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 24

Respodent: “Amerian College University” (Skopje) 21

Group C:

Applicant:“American College University” (Skopje)

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Trajkovska, Katić, Carić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Trajkovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Katić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Carić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “American College University” (Skopje) 22

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Group D:

Applicant:“Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Judges: Vučinić, Rovšek, Nikolovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Vučinić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Rovšek	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Nikolovska	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 29

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 16

Group D:

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Respodent: “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica)

Judges: Carić, Rovšek, Zupančić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Carić	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Rovšek	A 5	R 2	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Zupančić	A 5	R 2	A 4	R 1	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 31

Respodent: “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica) 14

Group D:

Applicant: “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica)

Respodent: “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Judges: Martinović, Nenadić, Vučinić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Martinović	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nenadić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Vučinić	A 2	R 5	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica) 18

Respodent: “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 27

Final results in all groups/divisions

A

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 54

Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje) 42

Club “Nasciturus” (Split) 39

B

Club”Iustitia” (Nis) 55

Club “Iudex” (Sarajevo) 43

Club “Discretio” (Mostar) 37

C

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 49

Club “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 43 (better in briefs)

Club “American College University” (Skopje) 43

D

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 56

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 47

Club “Gavro Vuković” (Podgorica) 32

PART IV

Semi-final

(April 21)

Draw

Four best clubs from each group/divisions and two second-best clubs were participated in the semi-final. According to draw results, groups E and F were formed:

E

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Club “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

F

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Club “Iustitia” (Niš)

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Matches in semi-final groups

(April 20)

Group E:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Judges: Popovic, Nikolovska, Pazin

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Popovic	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Pažin	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 22

Respodent: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 23

Group E:

Applicant: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

Respodent: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

Judges: Trajkovska, Popović, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Trajkovska	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Popović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Zupančić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 24

Respodent: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 21

Group E:

Applicant: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Carić, Nikolovska, Trajkovska

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Carić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 2	R 5	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Trajkovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 18

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 27

Group F:

Applicant:“Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Niš)

Judges: Carić, Zupančić, Vučinić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Carić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Zupančić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Vučinić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant:“Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 24

Respodent: “Iustitia” (Niš) 21

Group F:

Applicant:“Iustitia” (Niš)

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Judges: Carić, Pažin, Katić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Carić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 1	R 2
Pazin	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Katić	A 3	R 4	A 1	R 4	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: “Iustitia” (Niš) 18

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 27

Group F:

Applicant:“Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Respodent: “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad)

Judges: Nenadić, Katić, Martinović

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Nenadić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 2	R 1
Katić	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Martinović	A 3	R 4	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 23

Respodent: “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 22

Final results in semi-final

E

Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 49

Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb) 47

Club “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar) 39

F

Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 50

Club “Radomir Lukić” (Novi Sad) 46

Club “Iustitia” (Niš) 39

PART V

Final

(April 21)

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Judges: Popovic, Trajkovska, Zupančić, Martinovic, Nikolovska, Vučinić, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Popović	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Trajkovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Zupančić	A 6	R 1	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Martinović	A 4	R 3	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Vučinić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Nenadić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1

Total:

Applicant:“Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 63

Respodent: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 42

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

Judges: Popovic, Trajkovska, Zupančić, Martinovic, Nikolovska, Vučinić, Nenadić

Judge	Argumentation		Performance		Answer
Popović	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Zupančić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Trajkovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2
Nikolovska	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 0	R 3
Vučinić	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Martinović	A 4	R 3	A 3	R 2	A 2	R 1
Nenadić	A 3	R 4	A 2	R 3	A 1	R 2

Total:

Applicant: “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka) 47

Respodent: “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana) 58

PART VI

The winner

The Club “Henrik Steska” from Ljubljana is the winner of the Seventh Regional Moot Court Competition with 121 points, while “Zoran Kompanjet” from Rijeka is the second with 89 points.

PART VII

The final results of the second part of the competition

1. Club “Henrik Steska” (Ljubljana)

2. Club “Zoran Kompanjet” (Rijeka)

3. Club “Vladimir Bayer” (Zagreb)

4. Club “Radomir Lukic” (Novi Sad)

5. Club “Iustitia” (Nis)

6. Club “Džemal Bijedić” (Mostar)

7. Club “Iudex”(Sarajevo)

8. Club “Iustiniana Prima” (Skopje)

9. “Americal College University” (Skopje)

10. “Nasciturus” (Split)

11. Club “Discretio” (Mostar)

12. Club “Gavro Vukovic” (Podgorica)

Belgrade, Secretary of the

Administrative Board

22 April 2013 Goran Miletić